The Houston Astros made the biggest move of the MLB offseason by trading Kyle Tucker, their three-time All-Star right fielder, to the Chicago Cubs. It was a tough decision but Astros general manager Dana Brown said it was part of the plan to win now and build for the future. Here’s why Tucker was traded and what the Astros got back.
The Decision to Trade Kyle Tucker
Trading Tucker wasn’t easy for Dana Brown who called it “the hardest thing” he’s done since becoming the Astros’ GM in January 2023. But the opportunity to rebuild the roster and build for the future was too good to pass up.
“It was very difficult [to trade Tucker], but we saw an opportunity there to be good in the future and build toward the future,” Brown said on Foul Territory with former MLB catcher A.J. Pierzynski.
Tucker is a short term asset and becoming a free agent after the 2025 season. The Astros weren’t going to sign him to a $300 million plus extension so trading him before his walk year made sense. It allowed the Astros to get younger cost controlled talent that fits the long term vision.
.@Astros GM Dana Brown says the "hardest thing" he had to do was trading Kyle Tucker pic.twitter.com/2UD7Spy4iF
— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) March 5, 2025
What the Astros Gained in the Trade
In return for Tucker the Astros got three players: third baseman Isaac Paredes, starting pitcher Hayden Wesneski, and top prospect Cam Smith. Each brings something different to the table:
1. Isaac Paredes: A Utility Bat
Paredes has already shown flashes of his potential this spring, hitting .300 with a home run yanked over the left-field fence at CACTI Park of the Palm Beaches. He can play multiple infield positions and adds depth to the lineup.
2. Hayden Wesneski: A Reliable Arm
Wesneski has been impressive on the mound, striking out six batters and allowing one run across four innings in two separate appearances. He’ll be a good member of the 2025 staff.
3. Cam Smith: The Future Star
Smith is the headliner of the trade and has been the buzz in camp. The Florida State product and 2024 1st round pick has 2 HR and 1 3B in 7 at-bats . He won’t impact 2025 but should be a cornerstone of the franchise in 2026 and beyond.
The Financial Advantage
Beyond getting talent, the trade also brought financial benefits to the Astros. By trading Tucker—a soon to be free agent—the team got over a decade of cheap contracts:
- Isaac Paredes: Under control until 2027
- Hayden Wesneski: Under control until 2027
- Cam Smith: Under control until at least 2029
“You get 14 years of control for one year of control,” Brown said, pointing out the value of getting players with extended control.
This allows Houston to be competitive and still not break the bank and not have to sign star players to giant contracts.
The Emotional Hit to Fans
For Astros fans, watching Tucker leave is gonna hurt. He was a cornerstone of the franchise, contributed offensively and defensively. Tucker could very well finish top 5 in MVP in 2025—this time in the National League—which will just sting even more for Houston fans.
And to make it worse, Tucker isn’t the only former cornerstone leaving this winter. The Astros have lost several key pieces and fans are wondering what’s the direction of the team. But Brown says the moves were necessary for long term success.
Spring Training Notes
So far the new guys are making a good impression in spring training:
- Paredes is showing power and consistency at the plate.
- Wesneski is showing command and effectiveness on the mound.
- Smith is electrifying the clubhouse with his talent and potential.
This is good news the trade will pay off sooner rather than later.